Sydney CivilEstimating

Case studies

What we found when we priced it

Four recent civil and stormwater tenders, anonymised. We don't name clients or sites, and we wouldn't name yours. Each one shows the type of work, the tender value range (ex GST), what came up when we priced it from first principles, and what that changed for the client.

Civil works$500k to $1M

Small housing development

What we foundThe geotech showed very high strength rock from about a metre down. We priced it as its own item, with the hammer slowed by vibration limits at the boundaries, instead of excluding it. We also picked up temporary shoring needed beside existing footings on a boundary drainage line.
What it changedThe rock and the shoring went in as priced items with their own quantities, so the tender carried the real cost instead of an exclusion the client could argue about later.
Stormwater$400k to $500k

Car park drainage

What we foundWe rebuilt the network from the invert levels, not the plan. Following the note leaders showed three of the pits were existing, not new.
What it changedThree pits came out of the price, and the pipe lengths and depths were taken from the levels, so the price matched what would be built.
Stormwater$500k to $1M

Drainage for a landscape upgrade

What we foundWe measured the pipes off the long sections and checked every length against the chainages; measuring the plan's colours would have doubled the length. We flagged that the detention tank had no structural design, and priced precast against cast in situ: precast came in at under half the cost.
What it changedThe client tendered with the precast option and a written assumption on the missing tank design, instead of carrying a cast in situ price and the design risk.
Stormwater$1M to $2M

Diversion through an easement

What we foundLarge pipe and box culvert, 2 to 3 m deep. The bridging structure and piles were agreed out of scope and written up as exclusions, so the price covered only what was drawn.
What it changedA clean scope line: the drawn works priced in full, the undesigned structure named as an exclusion, nothing left for the client to assume either way.

Why these things get found

None of this is clever. It comes from pricing the job the way it gets built: the pipes off the long sections and invert levels rather than the plan, the rock off the geotech rather than a note, the structures off the details rather than the legend. When a tender is priced in a hurry, those are the steps that get skipped, and they are where the money is.

Every estimate we hand over comes with the same things:

  • A priced bill of quantities in Excel and PDF, item by item, with the quantity, unit and rate for each line.
  • Assumptions and exclusions written down, so you know exactly what the number covers.
  • The risks named, with an allowance where one is sensible and a flag where it is your call.
  • Questions for the designer, worth sending before the tender closes.
  • The estimator on the phone for questions, before and after you submit.

If you want to see how we check a tender before it goes in, the tender check guide and the free Civil Tender Scope Check cover the same ground.

Send us the RFQ

The tender documents, drawings and closing date. We'll come back with a fee and a delivery date, usually the same business day.

CallWhatsAppSend RFQ